The Yellowstone Season 5 Part 2 trailer has sparked intense speculation, and this new theory about Beth finally killing Sarah takes the drama to new levels! The idea that Beth and Jamie might be working together in an elaborate ruse to outmaneuver Sarah and Market Equities is definitely one of the more intriguing and mind-bending possibilities.
As you mentioned, the dynamic between Beth and Jamie has been one of the most volatile and unpredictable aspects of the series. After Part 1 ended with both siblings plotting against each other, fans naturally assumed that a full-blown war was inevitable. Beth threatening Jamie and Jamie planning to have her killed with Sarah’s help seemed to set the stage for an explosive showdown.
However, this theory flips the script entirely. It suggests that Beth and Jamie could actually be collaborating in a secret plan to take down Market Equities. This would explain why Beth was seemingly one step ahead, showing up at Jamie and Sarah’s first date—almost as if she was in on it. The idea that John Dutton might be willing to sacrifice his governorship for a larger goal also adds weight to the theory. John has never been particularly invested in politics for its own sake, and if losing his position means he can safeguard the Yellowstone Ranch, it might be a price he’s willing to pay.
If Jamie and Beth are indeed working together, it would represent a massive twist—one that could completely change the narrative of Season 5 Part 2. The idea that Sarah will ultimately be the one who gets caught in the crosshairs, while Jamie ascends to power as governor, is wild, but as you said, nothing is off-limits in the Yellowstone universe.
Is this theory likely? Well, given Taylor Sheridan’s track record of surprising his audience, it’s not out of the question. Beth and Jamie’s long history of betrayal makes the idea of them teaming up seem unlikely, but that’s what would make this twist all the more shocking.
Fans are divided: Some believe this theory has merit, pointing to the unpredictability of the Duttons’ strategies and the way the show often subverts expectations. Others think it’s too far-fetched, arguing that the animosity between Beth and Jamie runs too deep for them to ever work together, even against a common enemy like Market Equities.
In any case, Season 5 Part 2 is shaping up to be an intense, action-packed ride with a potentially game-changing finale. Whether this theory holds true or not, the battle between the Duttons and their enemies is bound to be explosive.
Let me know if you think this theory is plausible, or if Beth and Jamie are too far gone for any kind of alliance. Either way, the countdown to Part 2 is on!
